By Jonathan A. Fox
How can the seeds of responsibility ever develop in authoritarian environments? Embedding responsibility into the country is an inherently asymmetric, partial and contested method. Campaigns for public responsibility frequently win constrained concessions at top, yet they could depart cracks within the procedure that function handholds for next efforts to open up the nation to public scrutiny. This booklet explores the how civil society ''thickens'' via evaluating 20 years of rural voters' struggles to carry the Mexican kingdom liable, exploring either swap and continuity sooner than, in the course of, and after nationwide electoral turning issues. The booklet addresses how a lot power-sharing particularly occurs in coverage techniques that come with participatory social and environmental councils, citizen oversight of elections, neighborhood executive social funding cash, participation reforms in international financial institution tasks, community-managed foodstuff courses, in addition to new social oversight and public info entry reforms. in the meantime, efforts to workout voice spread even as rural electorate examine their go out recommendations, as thousands migrate to the U.S., the place many have given that come jointly in a brand new migrant civil society. given that factors of electoral swap don't account for the way humans really adventure the nation, this booklet concludes that new analytical frameworks are had to comprehend ''transitions to accountability.'' This comprises unpacking the interplay among participation, transparency and responsibility. Oxford stories in Democratization is a sequence for students and scholars of comparative politics and similar disciplines. Volumes pay attention to the comparative learn of the democratization approach that followed the decline and termination of the chilly battle. The geographical concentration of the sequence is essentially Latin the United States, the Caribbean, Southern and jap Europe, and suitable reviews in Africa and Asia. The sequence editor is Laurence Whitehead, legit Fellow, Nuffield university, college of Oxford.
Read or Download Accountability Politics: Power and Voice in Rural Mexico PDF
Similar comparative politics books
Roman legislation has had a big impact on ecu criminal and political proposal. Peter Stein, one of many world's prime felony historians, explains during this masterly brief examine how this got here to be. He assesses the influence of Roman legislations within the old international, and its endured unifying impact all through medieval and glossy Europe.
While the Soviet Union pulled its forces out of Afghanistan, the yankee media had an easy rationalization: Soviet troops have been hounded out of the mountains through U. S. -armed guerrillas--the skies cleared of Soviet plane by way of Stinger missiles--until the Kremlin was once compelled to cry uncle. yet Diego Cordovez and Selig S.
Prime anthropologists and political scientists are introduced jointly during this quantity to discuss the matter of comparability, taking over quite a few subject matters from nationalist violence and hard work moves to ritual varieties and non secular practices. The members criticize traditional different types of comparative approach, and introduce new comparative recommendations, starting from summary version development to ethnographically established tools.
Debates on immigrant integration frequently middle on “national types of integration,” an idea that displays the need of either researchers and coverage makers to discover universal flooring. This e-book demanding situations the concept that there has ever been a coherent or constant Dutch version of integration and asserts that notwithstanding Dutch society has lengthy been visible as exemplary for its multiculturalism—and argues that the incorporation of migrants is still one of many country’s so much urgent social and political issues.
- The Limits of Soviet Power in the Developing World
- Mastering British Politics
- Being Modern in Iran
- Understanding China's Legal System
- Comparing Political Regimes: A Thematic Introduction to Comparative Politics
Additional info for Accountability Politics: Power and Voice in Rural Mexico
As O’Donnell pointed out, the impact of civil society pressure for accountability of public authorities ‘depends to a large extent on the actions that properly authorized state agencies may undertake in order to investigate and eventually sanction the wrongdoings’ (1999: 30). Civil society’s usual deployment of symbolic rather than legal sanctions leads some analysts to consider them to be inherently weak (Schedler 1999: 16), but Smulovitz and Peruzzotti argue that social accountability can have ‘material consequences’ by ‘turning on the alarm’ in ways that activate electoral or ofﬁcial horizontal accountability processes (2003: 311).
Sanction is an elastic concept. . (F)or many people, the fact that one must appear before a forum in order to explain one’s conduct is already experienced as a demarche. It signiﬁes that one is not trusted. . The sanction is therefore present in the very process of being held responsible’ (1998: 40). This argument relies on normative assumptions that fall apart when the gap between the transgression and the ‘answerability’ process is very large. In such cases, the process of ‘calling to account’ may be experienced as inconvenient by those called to account, but still allows them to, for example, get away with murder.
For a more profound example, until recently, in most societies, intrafamily violence against women was not considered to be a crime. As a result, the police did not enforce laws against physical abuse. Feminist civil society campaigns then shifted the boundary between public and private by means that ranged from cultural interventions to women’s urban–popular organizations distributing whistles in their neighborhoods (Stephen 1997: 138). The goal was to—literally—blow the whistle on intrafamily violence.